cake pop

Easy Cake Pop Recipe – How to Make Cake Pops from Homemade Cake (Chocolate Cake Style)

Spread the love

The Easy Cake Pop Recipe That Actually Works (With Homemade Frosting!)

How many times have you tried to make the perfect cake pop only to end up with lopsided balls, cracked chocolate, or frosting oozing out like a disaster in slow motion? If you’ve been there — standing in your kitchen with a cake ball falling off the stick again — you’re not alone. And yes, there’s a better way to get that bakery-style bite: cakesicles, the upgraded cousin of the classic cake pop.

These easy cake pops (yes, technically shaped like popsicles) solve every issue you’ve had with traditional cake pops. They’re bigger, easier to handle, and you won’t need to dip the cake in a deep cup of melted chocolate and hope for the best. With cakesicles, you paint the chocolate coating inside a mold, press in your cake and frosting mixture, and seal it like a pro — even if you’ve never frosted a cupcake in your life.

And let’s be honest — you’re not just looking for any cake pop recipe. You want the best cake pops that taste like something from a café, maybe even a little like a Starbucks cake pop, but without all the fuss. Whether you’re starting with a box cake mix, some leftover cake, or going full homemade cake pop mode, this guide walks you through how to make the cake, crumble the cake, mix it, mold it, and master it.

We’ll cover everything from prepping the cake mixture, making cake from scratch (or using a boxed cake mix), to choosing between white chocolate, dark chocolate, or candy melts. We’ll even talk storage, freezing, decorating, and — yep — what not to do (like ruining the perfectly round cake by dipping too soon).

If you’re here to make cake pops that don’t just look good but actually taste amazing, you’re in the right place. Let’s learn how to make your new favorite dessert: Cakesicles — the cake pop you actually want to eat.

Ingredients for Homemade Cake Pops (with Cake Mix & Frosting)

Before you can make cake pops that actually hold together and taste delicious, you need a solid base. Whether you’re going for a vanilla cake pops vibe or a deep chocolate cake feel, this list keeps things simple. You can start with a homemade cake or use a box cake mix and canned frosting. Both paths lead to a perfectly round cake ball — it just depends on how much time you’ve got.

For the Cake Pop Base (Cake & Frosting Mix):

  • 1 full cooled cake (use box cake mix or make the cake from scratch)
  • ⅓ to ½ cup frosting (homemade frosting or cream cheese frosting)
  • Optional flavor additions: vanilla extract, crushed cookies, fruit zest

You can make the frosting yourself or use a ready-made tub. If using box cake mix or canned frosting, make sure your cake is fully cooled before crumbling — that’s key to avoiding a mushy cake mixture. Want the best cake pops? Let the cake cool completely before mixing.

Pro Tip: Use chocolate fudge cake + cream cheese frosting for a tangy twist. It’s basically what Starbucks cake pops dream of being.

For the Chocolate Shell:

  • 16–32 oz melted chocolate (choose from:
    • white chocolate
    • dark chocolate
    • candy melts
    • or use chocolate chips or almond bark)
  • Popsicle mold (for cakesicles)
  • Popsicle or cake pop sticks

If you’re using melted chocolate for dipping instead of molds, remember: you’ll need to dip the cake ball, not just coat it. Insert the pop stick into the melted chocolate, then place the cake balls into the shell. Want less mess? Cakesicle molds eliminate dripping excess chocolate and keep your cake pop upright.

Whether you’re working with a cake mix for these cake balls, or baking a moist cake from scratch, the ingredients stay simple — which is why this is often called a 3 ingredient cake pops setup.

What kind of cake mix is best for cake pops?

Honestly, any cake mix works — but for flavor and stability, go with Duncan Hines or Betty Crocker. Chocolate fudge for depth, or red velvet if you’re feeling dramatic (yes, red velvet cake makes stunning pops).

Step-by-Step Instructions to Make Cake Pops with Cake Mix

Making cake pops doesn’t have to feel like juggling sugar grenades. Here’s how to make your cake balls firm, flavorful, and fuss-free — whether you’re using a box cake mix or going full homemade cake pop from scratch. These instructions walk you through everything: from how to bake the cake, crumble the cake, make the frosting, and shape the cake ball — to the final dip the cake pop moment.

Step 1: Bake the Cake and Let It Cool

  • Follow the instructions on your box cake mix (or make the cake from scratch).
  • Use milk instead of water and add a spoon of instant pudding mix for a moist cake.
  • Once baked, allow the cake to cool completely before continuing.

Don’t rush this! Trying to mix or shape a warm cake is a recipe for gooey disaster.

Step 2: Crumble the Cake & Mix with Frosting

  • Crumble the cooled cake into a large mixing bowl.
  • Add ⅓ to ½ cup of frosting (store-bought or homemade frosting).
  • For extra tang, use cream cheese frosting.
  • Mix until you get a dense, truffle-like cake mixture.

You want it sticky but not wet. Too much frosting, and you’ll ruin the texture. Too little, and the pops crumble.

This cake and frosting combo is what makes the center of the cake pop melt-in-your-mouth good.

Step 3: Shape the Cake Balls

  • Scoop about 1 tablespoon of the cake mixture and roll it into a ball.
  • Focus on forming a perfectly round cake ball — gently roll between palms.
  • Place the cake balls on a lined tray.

You’ll want to chill the cake balls in the refrigerator for at least 30 minutes. Cake balls are too cold? Let them sit for 5–10 minutes before dipping.

This stage is when the center of the cake ball firms up enough to coat properly.

Step 4: Melt the Chocolate & Prep the Sticks

  • Melt the chocolate (dark, white, or candy melts) in 30-second bursts in the microwave.
  • Stick into the melted chocolate, then press halfway into the cake ball.
  • Let them set upright. This step anchors your cake pop stick securely.

Pop stick into the melted chocolate = no wobbly pops later.

Step 5: Dip, Coat & Let Set

  • Gently dip the cake pop into the chocolate coating — not too fast, or you’ll lose it.
  • Tap off excess chocolate while rotating slowly.
  • Place the cake pop upright in a styrofoam block or drying stand.

Remember to coat the cake balls fully and let them harden at room temp — not the fridge, unless using candy melts.

What is the trick to making cake pops?

Two words: temperature control. Always let the cake cool, chill your shaped pops, and never dip the cake ball when it’s straight from the fridge — that causes cracks and separation. Timing is the real trick behind perfect cake pops.

Tips & Tricks to Make Perfect Cake Pops Every Time

Even with the best cake pop recipe, things can go sideways — cracked shells, falling sticks, or pops that taste like pure frosting. Here’s how to fix all that and actually make cake pops that look pro and taste even better.

Chill, but Not Too Much

  • After shaping your cake balls, place the cake balls in the refrigerator for 30–60 minutes.
  • Don’t dip the cake ball right out of the fridge. Cake balls are too cold? They’ll expand and crack your melted chocolate shell.
  • Let them rest 5–10 minutes at room temp before dipping.

Timing keeps your cake pop smooth, shiny, and crack-free.

Support the Stick Like a Pro

  • Always stick into the melted chocolate first, then insert the cake pop stick halfway into the cake ball where it meets the center.
  • Let it firm up before dipping. This adds grip and avoids droopy pops.

Want pops that don’t fall apart? This is how you make your cake balls stable.

Avoid Ruining the Coating

  • Use high-quality white chocolate, dark chocolate, or candy melts.
  • If reusing chocolate, don’t overheat — or your melted chocolate will seize.
  • Always melt the chocolate slowly and stir between bursts.

Uneven heating is how you get grainy coating — no thanks.

Balance Your Frosting Ratio

  • Too much frosting = mushy mess. Too little = dry cake ball.
  • Start small and adjust. For ultra-smooth texture, blend in a stand mixer.
  • Cake mix and canned frosting are fast but may need chilling to firm up.

Clean Your Dips

  • After dipping, spin gently and tap off excess chocolate.
  • Let the shell set fully before adding sprinkles or drizzle.
  • Never rush drying in a cold room — moisture ruins the shine.

What is the secret to smooth cake pops?

Perfect timing, chilled cake balls, and thinned-out chocolate. Add ½ tsp of coconut oil to candy melts or use chocolate chips melted low and slow. And don’t forget: insert the stick, chill, then dip the cake pop into the chocolate.

Cake Pop Variations: Chocolate Cake, Themed Pops & More

If you’ve mastered the base cake pop recipe, it’s time to get creative. From classic chocolate cake versions to vibrant vanilla cake pops, themed designs, and even seasonal flavors — you can make cake pops that match any mood, holiday, or craving.

Classic Flavors That Always Win

  • Chocolate Cake Pops: Deep, rich, and crowd-pleasing. Use a box cake mix with fudge flavor or make the cake with cocoa and espresso powder for intensity.
  • Red Velvet Cake Pops: Bold color and soft tang, especially with cream cheese frosting.
  • White Cake Pops: Light and versatile. Perfect with sprinkles or fruit-flavored drizzle.

These are the best cake pops to gift or bring to a party — familiar but always polished.

Creative and Themed Cake Pops

  • Unicorn or Galaxy Pops: Swirl white chocolate with color drops.
  • Holiday Pops: Think snowman, pumpkins, or hearts using food pens or shaped molds.
  • Cakesicles (aka cake pop popsicles): Use silicone molds instead of shaping by hand. Easier to coat the cake balls, and they place the cake pop perfectly flat while drying.

These variations are ideal when making cake pops completely from scratch or for events like birthdays and showers.

Minimalist 3-Ingredient Cake Pops

If you’re short on time, go for 3 ingredient cake pops: just a box cake mix, frosting recipe (or canned), and melted chocolate. They’re simple, fast, and totally customizable. Perfect when you’re using cake mix for these cake balls without extra add-ins.

What are Starbucks cake pops made of?

They typically use crumbled cake (usually vanilla or chocolate), blended with frosting, shaped into a cake ball, then dipped in melted chocolate. Yep, you can replicate that Starbucks cake vibe at home for way less.

Easy Cake Pop Recipe (From Scratch)

cake pop

Easy Cake Pop Recipe

Yield: 24 pops
Prep Time: 1 hour
Cook Time: 30 minutes
Additional Time: 30 minutes
Total Time: 2 hours

These easy chocolate cake pops are moist, rich, and coated in smooth melted chocolate. Whether you use a cake mix or homemade cake and frosting, they’re fun, freezer-friendly, and party-perfect every time.

Ingredients

Cake Pop Base

  • 1 full cake, cooled completely (box mix or homemade)
  • ⅓ to ½ cup frosting (homemade or canned)
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract (optional)
  • 2 tbsp crushed cookies or fruit zest (optional)

Chocolate Coating

  • 16 to 32 oz melted chocolate (white, dark, or candy melts)
  • 1 tbsp coconut oil (optional, to thin chocolate)

Instructions

  1. Bake the Cake
    Bake the cake according to your box or homemade recipe. Let it cool completely before crumbling.
  2. Make the Cake Pop Mixture
    Crumble the cooled cake into a large bowl.
    Add ⅓–½ cup of frosting and mix until the texture is dense and smooth, like truffles.
  3. Shape the Cake Balls
    Scoop about 1 tbsp of mixture and roll into balls.
    Chill in the fridge for 30–60 minutes to firm up.
  4. Melt Chocolate & Prep Sticks
    Melt chocolate in short microwave bursts.
    Dip one end of each stick in chocolate, then press into the cake ball. Let set 10 minutes.
  5. Coat the Cake Pops
    Dip each chilled pop into melted chocolate.
    Tap off excess and set upright in a stand to dry.
  6. Optional Decoration
    Once set, decorate with sprinkles, drizzle, or edible pens.
  7. Storage
    Store in an airtight container at room temp (3 days) or fridge (up to 1 week).

    8. Notes

  8. Always let the cake cool fully before mixing — it avoids sogginess.
  9. Add a small amount of coconut oil to the chocolate to get a smoother, glossier finish.
  10. Chill shaped cake balls before dipping, but don’t dip straight from the fridge — let them rest 5–10 minutes first.

    11. Nutrition Information:
    Yield: 24 Serving Size: 1 Pop
    Amount Per Serving: Calories: 175Total Fat: 9gSaturated Fat: 5gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 4gCholesterol: 22mgSodium: 95mgCarbohydrates: 23gNet Carbohydrates: 22.5gFiber: 0.5gSugar: 15gProtein: 1.5g

    Nutrition information is estimated based on standard ingredients and serving size. For the most accurate data, consult your nutrition app or tools.

    © sweetcakerecipe
    Cuisine: American / Category: Dessert

    Frequently Asked Questions About Making Cake Pops

    These are the questions most first-time (and even repeat) bakers ask when trying to make the best cake pops. Here’s what you need to know before that next cake ball disaster strikes.

    What is the trick to making cake pops?

    Temperature control and balance. Let the cake cool, chill the cake balls, and don’t overdo the frosting. Use a cake mix and canned frosting combo if you’re starting out — it’s more forgiving. Always dip the cake pop using steady hands, and avoid over-handling the chocolate coating.

    What not to do when making cake pops?

    • Don’t skip chilling — cake balls and the melted chocolate need time to set.
    • Don’t dip the cake ball straight from the fridge — it leads to cracks.
    • Don’t overload the pop — too much frosting or thick melted chocolate creates mess.

    Also, avoid ruining the perfectly round cake by using too much force when inserting the stick.

    How far in advance can I make cake popsicles?

    You can make cake balls ahead of time and freeze them up to 3 months. Once dipped, cake pops are the perfect prep-ahead treat — just store them in a cool, dry spot.

    Can you make cake pops and freeze them?

    Yes! Cake balls from the refrigerator can be frozen, but fully dipped pops do best wrapped in plastic, placed in a box, and thawed slowly to avoid sweating. Just allow the cake to cool first before freezing.

    Is it better to make cake pops the day before?

    Absolutely. This gives time to place the cake balls, let them chill, and ensure the melted chocolate fully sets. Plus, flavors settle in overnight — especially if you’re using box cake mix or canned frosting.

    Homemade Cake Pop Nutrition (Per Serving)

    The calorie count for a single cake pop depends on your ingredients, but here’s a ballpark based on a standard 1-ounce serving using box cake mix and canned frosting plus a thin layer of melted chocolate.

    • Calories: 150–200 per pop
    • Fat: 7–11g
    • Carbs: 18–25g
    • Sugar: 12–18g
    • Protein: 1–2g

    Using homemade frosting or trimming the amount of chocolate coating can shave off a few calories. Want a slightly lighter version? Try vanilla cake pops with Greek yogurt-based frosting instead of buttercream.

    Also note, cakesicles — which are larger and thicker than a typical cake pop — will naturally have a higher calorie range, especially if you use chocolate with higher cocoa content or add fillings like caramel or cookie butter.

    Final Thoughts on Making the Best Homemade Cake Pops

    Let’s be honest — learning how to make cake pops isn’t just about dessert. It’s about that moment when a kid lights up at a chocolate cake pop, or when your guests ask, “Wait… you made these?” It’s about turning leftover cake into magic, transforming a cake ball into a smile.

    Whether you went the full homemade cake pop route or used a trusty box cake mix, what matters is that you tried. Maybe you got some excess chocolate on your hands. Maybe one cake pop stick wobbled a bit. That’s part of the charm.

    Now you know how to make the best cake pops, keep them from cracking, and even style them as cakesicles for more wow-factor. The recipe makes a full batch, so share them or freeze them for later. They’re party-ready, giftable, and honestly — addictive.

    So go ahead. Place the cake pop on the stand, stand back, and admire what you made from scratch (or almost). Because these aren’t just easy cake pops — they’re tiny, sweet proof that you nailed it.

    If you loved this tutorial, print the recipe card, leave a comment, or tag your best-looking cake and chocolate creation online. Let’s see your spin on the perfect cake pops!

    More Cake Recipes You’ll Love

    If you enjoyed this recipe, don’t miss some of our other favorite cake creations! Whether you’re in the mood for a rich chocolate treat or something light and fruity, there’s something here for every kind of cake lover:

    Explore more sweet ideas and let your next cake adventure begin!